Sweet Banana Pudding Recipe (2024)

Published: · Modified: by Jennifer · This post may contain affiliate links · 116 Comments

Have you seen the brand new Coffee-mate Extra Sweet & Creamy flavor on shelves yet? It is absolutely perfect for use in a Sweet Banana Pudding Recipe!

The new Coffee-mate Extra Sweet & Creamy flavor gives you a balanced cup of coffee with a delightfully creamy taste and a little extra touch of sweetness.

Y'all know how much I love my sugar, right? This new flavor is sweet enough that I don't need any added sugar in my coffee, but it's not too sweet. It's perfect!

Of course, Coffee-mate has several flavors with different levels of sweetness, ranging from Original, to Italian Sweet Cream, to the new Extra Sweet & Creamy, along with their delicious special flavored creamers.

But I thinkCoffee-mate's new Extra Sweet & Creamy might be my new favorite...for now, at least!

WhileCoffee-mate's smooth, creamy taste has been perfected to bring out the flavor in your coffee, did you know that you can also use it in place of milk in your favorite recipes?

I use coffee creamer as a substitute for milk whenever I'm working with a recipe that I think could benefit from a little extra flavor boost, like this classic banana pudding recipe.

Everyone loves banana pudding, right? By switching some of the milk for Coffee-mate Extra Sweet & Creamy coffee creamer, it kicks up the flavor just a notch, without taking away from the classic banana pudding goodness!

You need

Instant Jellobananapuddingmix

Some jars (the amountdepend on size)

Milk

mini vanilla wafers

bananas

First start by mixing your instantpuddingwith 2 cups of milk or follow the direction on thepackaging. Then set aside for a few minutes.

Get your jars and place some mini vanilla wafers in the bottom, Then a layer of bananas, sliced.

Then add another layer ofpudding and so on until your jar is filled to the top. Then you can sprinkle crumbled up vanilla wafers on top and somebananas.

Put a lid on it and enjoy for a snack later or on the go. You can also add a tag and give them out as gifts!

CRAVING MORE DELICIOUS RECIPES AND TRAVEL INSPIRATION?

Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Pinterest, Facebook, YouTube, and Instagram for all the latest updates! Sign up below to receive my newsletter filled with delicious recipes, fun crafts, and family adventures straight into your inbox:

Sweet Banana Pudding Recipe (4)

Sweet Banana Pudding Recipe with Coffee-mate Extra Sweet & Creamy Coffee Creamer

Jennifer

No ratings yet

Print Recipe Save Recipe

Ingredients

  • 1 box of Instant Jello banana pudding mix
  • 4 mason jars or dessert cups
  • 1 ½ cup Milk
  • ½ cup Coffee-mate Extra Sweet & Creamy Creamer
  • Mini Wafer Cookies - as many as you desire
  • 2 bananas sliced

Instructions

  • First start by mixing your instant pudding with 1 ½ cup of milk and ½ cup of Extra Sweet & Creamy Coffee-mate creamer. Place in the fridge for about 5 minutes so that it begins to set.

  • Get your jars and place some mini wafer cookies in the bottom, then add a layer of sliced bananas and a scoop of the pudding.

  • Repeat foranother layer of bananas and cookies, with a scoop of pudding until your jar is filled to the top.

  • Sprinkle crumbled up wafer cookies on top and a few slices of bananas for garnish.

Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Sounds easy enough, right? That cup of Coffee-mate Extra Sweet & Creamy coffee creamer adds just an extra touch of sweet, creaminess and it's so good!

You can follow Coffee-mate on Twitter for more delicious fun and giveaway opportunities!

Speaking of giveaways...I am hosting my very own giveaway forfive full-value Coffee-mate Coffee Creamer coupons for a $20 total value.The giveaway ends March 13 2014 and is open to US residents only.

How to Enter the Giveaway

Mandatory Entry -Leave me a comment telling me how you use your Coffee-mate!

Bonus Entries

Tweet out this blog post - leave me the URL in the comments. This can be done daily.

Follow Coffee-mate on Twitter - leave me your Twitter handle in the comments, letting me know you're following Coffee-mate!

Follow Coffee-mate on Pinterest - leave me your Pinterest user ID in the comments.

I was selected for this opportunity as a member of Clever Girls Collective and the content and opinions expressed here are all my own.

More Dessert Recipes

  • Oreo Mug Cake
  • Lemon Blueberry Cookies
  • Homemade Pistachio Shortbread
  • Carrot Cake Whoopie Pies

About Jennifer

Jennifer, AKA "The Rebel Chick," is a 40-something Gen Xer who strives to help her readers live their best lives possible with easy recipes, travel inspiration and lifestyle tips!

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Erika Bragdon

    I never would have thought to use Coffee Mate in pudding - yum!

  2. Tiffany T

    I use my coffee mate to make the creamiest iced coffee for the warm, sticky georgia summer days.

    (I tweeted this blogpost and followed coffee mate on instagram! @tiffanyngriffin)

  3. Tiffany T

    Meaning I followed them on twitter.. Duh! Sorry.

  4. Jennifer Soltys

    Oh my, that looks completely delicious. Since it's banana I can have it for breakfast right? 😉

  5. kristin

    YUM! What a delicious pudding!!!

  6. Candace

    This looks delicious and I love the little jars used for serving too! Bananas are something I always have in the house too.

  7. michelle rattan

    That looks so good

  8. candice

    I just bought some coffee mate natural bliss cinnamon flavor today. I love adding it into our french toast on sunday morning!

  9. Nicole B

    I love Banana Pudding. I want to dig into that jar you've got pictured. It looks delicious!

  10. Mistee Dawn

    That looks absolutely delicious. Thanks so much for sharing the recipe.

  11. susan

    I have never thought of putting Coffee Mate in pudding, but this looks amazing I would love to try it.

  12. Feliss (Two Little Cavaliers)

    I love banana pudding but for some reason never make it at home. Maybe I know I would eat it all myself so only have it on special occasions but your idea to make it extra creamy makes it too tempting not to do it.

    I have to admit I only use coffee creamer in coffee but I bet some of the flavored creamers would be a great addition to cake mixes to give the cake an extra tasty boost.

  13. Ellen Christian

    I love banana pudding. I never would have thought to put coffee creamer in it!

  14. Whispered Inspirations

    This looks absolutely amazing. I love Banana Pudding. This is super creative, now you have me craving this! 🙂

  15. brett

    do you know I've never tried banana pudding? not once! crazy. I hope I can find this new creamer in stores. it looks amazing

  17. Brittany C.

    I'm such a huge fan of banana pudding! Never thought of adding the Coffee Mate with it!

  18. Amanda Sakovitz

    I use it for my coffee.

  20. Cynthia R

    I use coffee mate whenever I make my own coffee smoothies frapachino things, makes it so creamy!

  21. Carly Peterson

    Oh mylanta!! That looks fantastic. My kids love banana pudding. I also never thought of using CoffeeMate in pudding! That looks so great, it may be my kids after school snack today! Thanks for the fun recipe.

  23. Cynthia R

    i follow Follow Coffee-mate on Twitter as @carawling2

  24. Mindy Grant

    I love using Coffee-mate as a substitute for milk in recipes, too! I have some coupons to try out this new flavor as well. I'll be doing that this weekend. I can't wait!

  25. Thomas Murphy

    I use coffee mate in my coffee.

  27. Tammi

    I really need to think outside the box sometimes, I've only used this for coffee. While I love my coffee, this looks delicious. I must try it - thanks for the recipe!

  28. Clair Boone

    I LOVE my coffee creamer but would never have thought to do this. Thanks so much for the great recipe, I love that it's kid friendly too!

  29. Elena

    I use it with my coffee

  31. latanya

    I use it to sweeten my coffee

  33. latanya

    I follow CoffeeMate on pinterest as sweetums82

  34. latanya

    I follow CoffeeMate on twitter as @sweetums82

  35. Pam

    I love coffeecake! It totally changes coffee and it's great for recipes.

  36. Pam

    Whoops, autocorrect got me! I meant coffeemate.

  37. Jessie C.

    I use it for coffee or baking.

  38. Jessie C.

    -https://twitter.com/tcarolinep/status/441743172905873409

  39. Jessie C.

    Follow Coffee-mate on Twitter @tcarolinep

  40. Courtney

    My daughter has a banana obsession! She'd absolutely love this pudding 🙂 Would have never thought to use Creamer!

  41. Tammilee

    I think you might be a mind reader! I just had a conversation with my Husband today about Banana Pudding. He mentioned oh so casually how much he would not complain if I happened to make banana pudding this week.

  42. Tina M

    I use coffee mate in my coffee.

  43. Tina M

    Follow Coffee-mate on Pinterest

  46. Pauline Cabrera

    This so much fun! I want to try this myself. Actually, banana is one of my favorite fruits and most of the time, I just eat like any one else. But your idea is totally awesome and I would really like to try it one of these days. 🙂

  47. Autumn Reo

    I totally made banana pudding last night, but I love this shortcut for making it for a quick dessert! Great recipe to pin for later.

  49. Jessie C.

    -https://twitter.com/tcarolinep/status/441950748272652288

  51. RICHA KAUL

    Love it! Thanks for sharing! 🙂

  54. Debi

    I love banana pudding but I have never thought to use creamer in it before.

  56. Susan Christy

    I use coffee-mate in my coffee - cafe mocha!

  57. Susan Christy

    Follow Coffee-mate on Twitter - susitravl

  58. Jessie C.

    -https://twitter.com/tcarolinep/status/442490248816123906

  59. Tara

    My husband likes French Vanilla in his coffee.

  61. mika

    I love to try this one then consume it outside my porch. Coming from Weekend re-Treat Link Party ! Come-by and visit my blog!

  62. Jessie C.

    -https://twitter.com/tcarolinep/status/442851484405731328

  67. Wendy Rozema

    I'd use it in my coffee!

  68. Julie

    My husband likes it in his hot cocoa and coffee
    thanks

  70. Julie

    follow coffeemate twitter @aunteegem

  73. Jessie C.

    -https://twitter.com/tcarolinep/status/443492036381917184

  78. Jessie C.

    -https://twitter.com/tcarolinep/status/443830259205423105

  79. natalie yeoman

    i will use it in my coffee in the morning

  81. jeannine s

    I use it to flavor my coffee. I never thought to use it in baking to add flavor. I need to try it

  82. Jessie C.

    -https://twitter.com/tcarolinep/status/444133961367687169

  85. Lynne

    I guess I am unoriginal! I just use it in my coffee!

  87. Lynne

    I'm following Coffee-mate on twitter. I am @grapet7

  89. Britni

    This pudding looks incredible, especially with the great Vanilla Wafers. Thanks for sharing on the weekend re-Treat link party. Hope you link up to the party again tomorrow!

    Britni @ Play. Party. Pin.

  90. Andi

    I never would have thought to add Coffee-Mate to my dessert recipe, but now I'm going to have to give it a try. You are on fire with the clever ideas this week! 🙂

  91. Mariah

    Looks delicious!

  92. Erica

    I am making some banana pudding this weekend, I'm gonna try this. I also follow coffee mate on twitter, http://twitter.com/Reeceecup

  93. Iris

    To make Italian sodas 7-up with liquid coffee mate or ice creamless root beer floats root beer and vanilla coffee mate oh and I also use it in my oatmeal

  94. deanna boyd

    I have only used it in my coffee. but now I will be looking at its uses in an ALL new way! thank you!!!

  95. onica

    I dont drink coffee but i use it in my hot chocolate

  96. Jennifer R.

    I use coffee-mate every day in my coffee! I don't want coffee without it! I need to try using it in recipes now!

  97. Shawn Yetter

    I am all for this Banana Pudding switch up. But I am a huge fan of the Hazelnut flavor. So I am quite curious if we add a splash of it to the Banana Pudding recipe, what deliciousness will follow.... Hhmmm... Great idea above for the ice cream less Root Beer Floats, and Italian Sodas! For the sodas, you will need to add either a flavored syrup or extract to get the fruity flavors that are not yet available in the creamers.

  98. E Taylor

    I use Coffee-Mate creamer in my oatmeal from time to time. It's a real treat.

  99. Amina

    I tried this recipe... followed exactly as it said and my pudding never thickened. The next day I threw it all out because it was just a mushy liquid mess.

  100. Melissa

    Yummmmm-o!

  101. Cameal St.Clair

    I use my Coffee-Mate in my cakes, coffee, hot coco, and teas. I must try this banana pudding recipe.

  102. Norma Barclay

    My husband make mash potatoes using coffee mate. They are the best tasting mash potatoes even the instant potatoes don't taste instant. Can not wait to try it with banana pudding

  103. shawna b

    I use it in cake mix recipes oh yummmmy

  104. G. Love

    I use it mu daughters oatmeal.

  105. Rada

    Coffee!!!

  106. Christy

    In my morning coffee!

  107. Ann

    I use coffeemate in my ice coffees!!

  109. Kimberly

    I realize the contest is over but I use the flavored coffee mate creamers in my pancake mix. Yummy...Oh so good. 🙂

  110. Cecilia

    What's the nutritional information on it?

  111. Mia

    Add some chia seeds to this banana pudding recipe. Sounds yummy!

  112. Mia

    I tweet this recipe! Yum....

  113. cleo wilson

    I wouldn't eat that , its not food.

  114. Dee Teske

    My good ol' go to that I love is to make my own ice coffee and add white chocolate coffee mate. Yum yum

  115. Kelly Venier

    I Love Coffee Mate products so much. I like to add them to cake mixes, it makes them so moist. Plus if you use a flavored one in a white or yellow mix your cake will taste flavored too.

  116. Crickett Pegram

    I use the coffee creamer to make snow cream just simply scoop up the snow and use your favorite flavor Coffee-Mate it makes it creamy and delicious

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sweet Banana Pudding Recipe (2024)
Top Articles
Hawaii Wildfires ─ Red Cross Providing Shelter, Comfort to Victims
28 Best SeeHD Alternatives Working Sites to Watch Movies - Business Magazine
Latest Posts
Tips for Building a Healthy Relationship - HelpGuide.org
9 Books Like Front Desk (Books to Read If You Loved Front Desk)
Article information

Author: Laurine Ryan

Last Updated:

Views: 5959

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Laurine Ryan

Birthday: 1994-12-23

Address: Suite 751 871 Lissette Throughway, West Kittie, NH 41603

Phone: +2366831109631

Job: Sales Producer

Hobby: Creative writing, Motor sports, Do it yourself, Skateboarding, Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Stand-up comedy

Introduction: My name is Laurine Ryan, I am a adorable, fair, graceful, spotless, gorgeous, homely, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.