Captain D's Cole Slaw - CopyKat Recipes (2024)

Captain D’s coleslaw is an incredible indulgence due to its perfect balance of sweet and savory flavors. Even though this copycat recipe is easy to make, it has an exceptional creaminess that perfectly matches Captain D’s classic coleslaw. Don’t pass up the opportunity to make it yourself!

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Easy coleslaw recipe

The summer begs for picnics and cool and refreshing salads. Are you looking for an easy coleslaw recipe? This is the one to make. This Captain Ds Cole Slaw recipe is made simply with chopped cabbage, chopped carrots, and a tangy, slightly sweet creamy dressing that is drizzled over these freshly chopped vegetables. It is hard to resist.

I am a huge fan of Captain D’s. This is one of the few chain fish and chip places around. I love fried fish when done in this style. While you shouldn’t enjoy it too often, it can be a nice treat.

Whenever I go to Captain D’s, the cole slaw is what I go for first. This is a creamy coleslaw, and I personally love the note of celery seed in this recipe. It adds something that most coleslaw does not have.

I love this side dish, it is an inexpensive recipe to make. So this classic coleslaw recipe is perfect for when you have a large crowd to serve. Homemade coleslaw tastes so much more than any store-bought version.

Yes, you can buy a large tub of coleslaw in the store, but I often find the crunch of the cabbage gone. Since this isn’t difficult to make, you should give this cabbage salad a try at home.

This creamy, crunchy homemade coleslaw is great for a BBQ or to take to potlucks.

Why Captain D’s cole slaw is so delicious

This coleslaw hits the mark when it comes to texture and flavor. It’s a dreamy comfort food, to say the least. The fresh and crispy cabbage and the silky dressing make it a great accompaniment to heartier dishes like batter-dipped fish or fish sandwiches.

This copycat Captain D’s coleslaw strikes the perfect happy medium between sweet and tangy, thanks to the ideal combination of sugar and vinegar. The recipe also includes celery seed, which adds a unique flavor to the dish.

Why you’ll love the recipe

Having a go-to coleslaw recipe is essential for everyone. If you’re tired of trying to find the perfect balance of flavors every time you make coleslaw, this recipe can be the one for you! It’ll help you achieve the same flavor as Captain D’s coleslaw.

This coleslaw recipe is a terrific side dish option for any occasion, whether you’re making a weeknight dinner or hosting a gathering. It only takes 15 minutes to prepare, and if you need to make a smaller or larger batch, it’s super easy to adjust the recipe accordingly.

Also, don’t feel limited to only eating it with seafood. There are plenty of other scrumptious ways to make use of it!

For example, you could use it as a topping for your burgers or add it to your chicken tacos. You can also incorporate it into salads, wraps, and various types of sandwiches. Don’t be afraid to get creative with it!

Ingredients

Here’s what you need to make Captain Ds cole slaw at home:

• Green cabbage (you can use prepared coleslaw mix that is already chopped)
• Carrot
• White onion
• Mayonnaise
• White Vinegar
• Sugar
• Celery seed or celery salt
• Salt (omit if using celery salt)

If you don’t have white vinegar, you can use apple cider vinegar or lemon juice. Just note it will change the flavor slightly.

How to Make Captain Ds Cole Slaw

1. Chop cabbage, carrot, and onion with a sharp knife. This is so the cabbage and veggies will have the same texture as Captain D’s. You can use a mandolin or food processor but it will produce a different cabbage cut.
2. Place the shredded cabbage mixture in a medium bowl.

3. To make the cole slaw dressing, place mayo, vinegar, sugar, celery seed, and salt in a small bowl.

3. Stir until dressing ingredients are combined.
4. Add dressing to the bowl with chopped vegetables.
5. Stir to combine vegetables with the dressing.
6. Refrigerate coleslaw for at least two hours before serving.

What to serve with Captain D’s coleslaw

There’s no better way to enjoy this coleslaw than to make Captain D’s battered dipped fish and hush puppies! Create your own delicious Captain D’s feast in the comfort of your home.

Another option is to make butterfly shrimp or breaded chicken tenders. In either instance, the balance of the fried food with the creamy coleslaw is always such a delicious dining experience.

How to store leftover coleslaw

You will want to keep your leftover coleslaw, it goes great with sandwiches, especially on a pulled pork sandwich. It’s also great on fish tacos. I recommend storing it in an airtight container and placing the container in the fridge for up to five days.

I do not recommend freezing this due to the creamy coleslaw dressing. If you want a type of coleslaw you want to freeze, I have you covered. Try my best coleslaw recipe for freezing.

How long does it last?

When properly stored, this refreshing coleslaw lasts approximately five days!

Love Captain D’s? Check out these Copycat Recipes

• Homemade Hush Puppies
• Captain D’s Fish and Chips

Top Fast Food Copycat Recipes

• Popeye’s Cajun Rice
• How to Make Cheese Curds like Culvers
• Wingstop Restaurants Regular Wings, Lemon Pepper
• Panera Menu Salads – Green Goddess
• Taco Bell Fresco Crunchy Taco
• Taco Bell Crispito
• Krispy Kreme Donut Recipe
• Arby’s Salads – Grilled Chicken and Pecan
• BK Sauces – Zesty
• Chick Fil A Chicken Nuggets Recipe
• Auntie Anne’s Recipe for Original Pretzels

Be sure to take a look at more of the best copycat restaurant recipes and easy side dishes.